Assessing the Impact of Conservation

Overview

Dr. Eric Dinerstein

Threats like climate change, armed conflict, and a scarcity of resources—compounded by globalization— complicate today’s conservation efforts. To meet these growing challenges, WWF and the conservation community must refine established techniques while exploring new approaches. WWF’s team of scientists leads the effort to identify the most effective conservation strategies using “impact evaluation,” a new application of the scientific method that draws upon best practices in the medical and education sectors.

What WWF Is Doing

Three people in boat testing water

WWF’s scientists partner with conservation actors around the world to answer critical questions about what works in conservation and why. Drawing on different scientific disciplines, participatory approaches, and systems thinking, our approach to monitoring, evaluation, and learning is rooted in collaboration and guided by the critical need to invest in conservation solutions that deliver positive results for both people and nature. Not only does our work aim to generate evidence to inform conservation, it seeks to draw insight from existing diverse knowledge sources and systems—including practitioner experience, traditional and Indigenous knowledge, and scientific research—to support program strategy, design, and implementation. We work with the environmental evidence and knowledge synthesis communities of practice to bring reliable and relevant evidence to bear to inform critical conservation decisions.

WWF scientists have developed information, tools, and methods in collaboration with the conservation community as well as linked sectors such as health, environmental management, development, computer and data science, to support organizational monitoring. These resources and collaborations enable WWF to generate, synthesize, and deliver evidence-based insights on critical topics—such as community-based conservation, governance of protected and conserved areas, and nature-based interventions. In particular, we work to harness technological innovations such as remote sensing, artificial intelligence, and data science capacities to support conservation actors to efficiently assess change.

Impact Evaluation Critical for the Future

WWF scientists believe that impact evaluation is critical to the future of conservation science. Leveraging our long-standing field presence around the globe, our extensive network of respected scientists, and a variety of collaborative relationships with organizations, governmental agencies and academic experts, WWF uses state-of-the-art methods to study key conservation strategies and test their claims. By rigorously documenting the biological and social effects of each strategy, explaining variation in their outcomes and, identifying successful strategies, WWF scientists hope to identify the keys to successful conservation.

Evidence-based Approach

Overfishing, coral reefs

Through our work, we systematically measure the impact of our efforts by comparing project sites against parallel “control” sites outside project areas. This evidence-based approach tracks projects over time and helps determine why some strategies are successful and others are not, encouraging more tailored solutions instead of one-size-fits-all strategies.

WWF is initially applying this method in the Coral Triangle and Namibia, and in our work related to forest certification. Our work seeks answers to tough questions:

  • How has the creation of marine protected areas affected impoverished local communities and coral reef diversity?
  • Which economic and environmental factors can lead to successful community-run conservancies?
  • When and how has certification of forests helped secure the biodiversity of those systems?

Projects

  • The Art and Craft of Systems Change

    At WWF, we are working to transform how we plan, implement and evaluate our programs so they can better adapt to the changing needs of our complex world. Through guiding principles, practical tools, and real-world stories, we strive to make systems thinking practical and accessible for those seeking to create inclusive, impactful, and adaptive solutions to today's toughest problems.

Experts